Friday, 30 October 2026

The Rivals

          There’s a certain rivalry between the Devonshire cities of Exeter and Plymouth, the nature of which might be akin to that of Edinburgh versus Glasgow, where the former is considered more genteel than the latter.

          Atop a hill, some seven miles southwest of the city, sits Exeter Racecourse, in the middle of which is a campsite, where I stayed one night last week, buffeted by the departing storm Austen – or Polystyrene, as it was named by us after it washed up loads of the stuff on our local beach in Plymouth. I was en route to poke around our rival city and see what it has to be snooty about.

          Well, a racecourse, for one – though such a facility seems, to me, superfluous, elitist and not without the taint of cruelty to animals. I know nothing about the lives of horse owners, breeders, trainers or jockeys but, on the face of it, not even the economics of a racecourse make much sense. It must be hard to make a profit with huge, fixed costs and a short season of races. I suppose the campsite is a clue to the possibility of ancillary activities that boost the revenue column.

          A few days previously, I had been to The Box, Plymouth’s award-winning municipal archive/gallery, for the opening of an exhibition, The Way We Live Now. It’s an exploration of ideas and attitudes relating to planning for community in the light of anticipated new investment to meet the challenges of housing shortage, High Street decay and other related issues.

          Plymouth has particular experience of urban reconstruction, as we are reminded by the showing of Jill Craigie’s 1946 film, The Way We Live*. The centre of the city was so badly damaged by the Luftwaffe that it was decided subsequently to raze what was left and build anew. A visionary scheme incorporating modern planning and architecture was developed and executed over the next few years. Jill Craigie’s film dramatizes the planning process with local people acting alongside professionals. Plymouth’s city centre is now a protected conservation area.

         Well, says the proud Exonian, most of our city centre is also protected by conservation orders – and so it is, though the criteria differ. Exeter is a not untypical mish mash of medieval and later historic buildings – including a cathedral – that elicit nostalgia and lend it the feel of a place with hidden depth and historic heft. Such centres, these days, are regarded as deserving protection, if only for the venal reason of being popular with tourists.

          The proud Plymothian (known locally as a ‘Janner’) may point to the distinction of being native of a city that also has medieval roots (the Barbican) but embraced modernity with its ambitious, post-war reconstruction and, whilst I cannot claim to be a Janner myself, I am uplifted daily by the optimistic, expansive architecture of their city centre.

          In Exeter, I sought out the municipal archive/gallery, the equivalent of Plymouth’s The Box (which was renovated, remodelled, retitled and reopened in 2022) and was unsurprised to find it housed in a Victorian structure named, prosaically, the Royal Albert Memorial Museum. There is a modern extension at the back, a glazed and elevated platform from which remnants of the city’s Roman wall may be observed, but it was closed for repairs. Otherwise, the displays within are top class and the contents reflect the city’s mercantile heritage.

          As to why John Lewis, Ikea and a host of posh retail outlets chose to do business in Exeter rather than more populous Plymouth: this can be explained, no doubt, by marketeers with demographic statistics to hand. An everyday clue might be found in the fact of Exeter University’s high status in the national rankings. But when it comes to native pride of place, ‘Janner’ says a lot. Why does Exeter have no equivalent demonym?

No comments:

Post a Comment